On Monday, January 18, 2021, former Supreme Court Justice Lord Sumption appeared on Julia Hartley-Brewer’s talkRADIO show to discuss the perils of lockdown:
From early last year, Lord Sumption has been a calm, rational opponent of lockdown.
Breitbart has a summary of the three-minute interview clip. Excerpts follow, emphases mine.
I am pleased that his stance has not changed:
Lord Sumption, who last month branded lockdowns “profoundly immoral” and “useless”, told talkRADIO’s Julia Hartley-Brewer on Monday: “We are in the process of turning a public health crisis into an economic, social, and educational disaster.
“We didn’t have to do this. One of the problems is that the government has never been prepared at least to acknowledge that it is necessary to weigh up one thing against another. We cannot have both: lockdown and a prosperous economy. The fact is that no country ever managed to reduce deaths by making itself poorer.”
He warned that this will have a long-term, generational effect:
Lord Sumption continued: “What we have is a lot of people in this country that because they are frightened, or in the case of the government because they are manipulative, are only prepared to look at part of what is actually a very complicated problem.
“You can’t just look at it as a public health issue because it’s a major economic issue. I’m not talking just about the prosperity of businesses, I’m talking about jobs, and how a generation of young people entering the job market is entering a void and the consequences of that are terrible.
“It’s going to live with them for years and years. Long after we’ve forgotten about COVID, they’ll be suffering from the consequences of this. The problem is that emotion is a tool for avoiding difficult choices and the idea that there are no difficult choices — in this case, that the answer is simply to lock down — is frankly absurd.”
Using independent sources, Breitbart supports Lord Sumption’s views about the economy and about the effect on NHS services in other areas:
A survey conducted by the Federation of Small Businesses (FSB) found that it is expected that around a quarter of a million small businesses will collapse as a result of the lockdown this year.
Reports since the beginning of the lockdowns have also revealed the cost to the nation’s wider wellbeing as NHS hospitals prioritised COVID care and cancelled other services, including a fall in chemotherapy attendance and early cancer referrals, and people dying on transplant waiting lists. There has also been a rise in people feeling depressed or suicidal.
The following graph shows that lockdown was — and is — not necessary. It shows deaths in England between 1971 and 2020. There was hardly an uptick last year:
LBC’s talk radio show presenter Maajid Nawaz has also been an outspoken opponent of lockdown.
Last Sunday, he put together an exhaustive thread — excerpts of which follow — about the dangers of lockdown worldwide, especially for children:
Lockdown is made for the middle class a) who have houses with gardens and b) who never have to worry about losing their jobs — public sector employees:
Ten months on, this is a never-ending downward spiral, where the rules change every few weeks and are often contradictory. More on that in another post.
2 comments
January 23, 2021 at 9:54 am
AC Harper
Whatever your views on ‘lockdown’ – and there is a lot of cherry picking of data on both pro and anti sides – I blame the Main Stream Media.
The MSM have repeatedly criticised the Government for everything they have done, and everything they have not done. Many of those criticisms are just because the Government is headed by Conservatives, and little respect for data integrity is shown during the pursuit of the day’s headline.
And as a consequence the government dare not allow the hospital corridors to be shown as stuffed with dying people for the sake of the economy. If that were the case we would have a forced General Election (or a heavily biased one) and I am far from convinced that a Kier Starmer led government would be any better.
LikeLiked by 1 person
January 23, 2021 at 12:24 pm
churchmouse
Keir Starmer would have been — and would be — far, far worse than BoJo. We’d be on perpetual lockdown.
I, too, blame MSM. They clamoured for the March lockdown. They got it. I don’t watch much BBC News (or any other MSM news) but, often, when I do tune in when channel hopping, there is often a pro-China segment on how a selected Chinese community battled coronavirus.
Also agree with you on the anti-Conservative bias, which is every bit as dangerous as the anti-Republican bias which seems to have infected the world’s media.
I despair.
LikeLike