You are currently browsing the tag archive for the ‘Question Time’ tag.

On Friday, November 22, 2019, a special two-hour Question Time was broadcast.

Fiona Bruce, the show’s host, moderated a discussion involving questions from a live audience put forward to the four main party leaders in half-hour segments.

The programme began with Jeremy Corbyn. Nicola Sturgeon of the SNP followed. The last two were Jo Swinson of the Liberal Democrats and Boris Johnson of the Conservative Party.

It was really sad to see that Boris Johnson’s Conservatives are the only political party running on a pro-Brexit platform. Labour favour a watery Brexit with a second referendum. Jo Swinson said in a previous interview on ITV last week that in the (unlikely) event she became Prime Minister, she would revoke Article 50 all by herself on the first day. The SNP are all about Scottish independence and only the Scots can vote for them. They, too, oppose Brexit and would appeal to the EU to allow Scotland to join as a separate nation.

Who won?

On Saturday, November 23, The Express reported on a poll it conducted among readers. Not surprisingly, most participants thought that Boris won (emphases mine):

A total of 50 percent of people believed the Conservative leader stole the show, with less than a quarter of readers (23 percent) convinced Jeremy Corbyn won.

Of the 22,368 people who voted in the poll, 11,307 believed Boris Johnson won – versus just 4,816 people. who voted for Mr Corbyn.

Of the four candidates, Jo Swinson seemed the least popular, with just eight percent – 1,776 people – believing she won the debate.

In fact, more people said they didn’t know who won – with this option being chosen by 1,924 people.

Coming third was Nicola Sturgeon, who teased a “less formal” arrangement with Labour to stop Brexit and end austerity, with 2,545 votes for the SNP leader.

One commenter, ‘fitz’, said the Prime Minister managed to “scrape through” after a tough start.

They said: “Boris had a tough job, but he scraped through ok at the end.

“I do not have any doubts that he will win the election with a modest majority of MPs who will support him.”

I hope that proves to be the case.

Nicola Sturgeon

Nearly all the leaders received tough questions from the audience. Nicola Sturgeon seemed to receive fewer:

I was hoping someone would ask her more about Scotland being financially self-sufficient post-independence without English money provided through what is called the Barnett Formula and what plans she would have for a Scottish currency. The SNP believe they can continue to use the British pound!

But I digress.

Sturgeon was adamant that Scots alone could decide the fate of the Union, which has existed since 1707:

Sturgeon relaxed with a book on the way back to Scotland:

Jo Swinson

Jo Swinson got a verbal blast from a Brexit supporter. The Express reported on the exchange:

Catherine, the audience member, asked: “Is revoking Article 50 confirming to 17.4 million people that you think we’re stupid and don’t know what we voted for?”

The Lib Dem leader said: “You cannot accuse us of not being upfront about wanting to stop Brexit. We have been crystal clear about that from the very beginning.

“Not for one second do I think that means you or anyone like you is stupid. I think it means we disagree.

“I really want us to be in a situation in this country where we can disagree with each other, Catherine.”

Ms Swinson continued: “That means that you want to leave, and I don’t think that makes you a bad person.

“I want to remain in the EU and I hope you think that doens’t make me a bad one.”

The audience member shot back: “You can disagree with me but you lost.

“You don’t get to keep disagreeing with me.”

Well said, Catherine.

On Saturday morning, Chuka Umunna, former Labour MP, now a Lib Dem parliamentary candidate, was asked on a BBC radio programme about Swinson’s Question Time performance and the Lib Dem’s anti-Brexit policy. The Express reports:

Mr Umunna, who standing in the cities of London and Westminster constituency on December 12, insisted the Liberal Democrat position to revoke Article 50 was not a mistake, despite Ms Swinson facing a tough grilling by furious audience members on the special leaders debate last night. The Labour-turned-ChangeUK-turned-Lib Dem politician told BBC Radio 4’s Today Programme: “No, there’s been no mistake made on this policy.”

Mr Umunna added: “It’s absolutely clear – you can’t save the NHS and address the issues in it at the same time as not seeking to stop Brexit, not least because 10 percent of our doctors come from the EU, and 7 percent of our nurses come from the EU.”

What no one from any party has addressed is WHY we have so few British doctors and nurses these days. I do not have an answer myself.

Anyway, The Express article related another audience member’s blast at Swinson on the Question Time special:

Ms Swinson faced yet another awkward encounter when another audience member branded the plan to stop Brexit “undemocratic”.

An audience member said: “You are not saying we will go back to the people, you are unilaterally saying ‘Revoke it.’

It’s undemocratic from somebody who wishes the last three and a half years had never happened.”

A startled Ms Swinson responded by saying the Liberal Democrats had campaigned for a so-called people’s vote for the past three years without getting the support in the House of Commons.

Swinson also received a grilling about her voting record when she was an MP in the Conservative-Lib Dem coalition government from 2010-2015. Swinson voted ‘Aye’ to more Conservative policies than Conservative MPs did during those years:

The woman asking that question was no ordinary member of the general public. To some viewers, her face seemed very familiar. They were not wrong. The woman is an actress:

That did not go down well with some viewers, and, in my humble opinion, rightly so:

Returning to Jo Swinson, the questions did no favours for the Lib Dems:

Jeremy Corbyn

Right at the outset, Jeremy Corbyn received a verbal smackdown from a long haired, bearded man:

Then, one of Corbyn’s supporters chimed in:

Corbyn’s position on Brexit has been rather nebulous, so, someone asked him about it:

This is what Corbyn said:

Boris Johnson

Boris confirmed to Fiona Bruce and the audience that he had been watching the programme backstage.

The Left have been hammering at Boris for an alleged lack of integrity. Yet, I cannot think of a single politician who has told the truth 100% of the time. Anyway:

As in the United States with the 2016 election, the Left are alleging that Russia interfered in the Brexit referendum campaign. Before Parliament was dissolved, Boris declined to release an official report about it, saying that, customarily, the Prime Minister reviewed such documents over a matter of weeks rather than days:

Someone brought up former Conservative MP, Dominic Grieve, a muckraking Remainer:

Boris got many more difficult questions.

He handled them well. Here he is on education:

And on Brexit:

Many of the questions and remarks were not fair, because he was not a sitting MP for most of the time the Conservatives have been in government. He was Mayor of London during several of those years, a fact that he put forward to the audience. He also said that he has been Prime Minister for only 120 days!

Overall, he managed a conversational tone with everyone, no matter how obnoxious they were:

Nearly everyone is upset over the blatant bias that Fiona Bruce and Mentorn Productions show on Question Time. Therefore, people overall — outside of Leftist activists — empathised with Boris, such as this journalist:

Boris also got a boost from this viewer:

And these:

The Prime Minister was gracious afterwards:


Outside of the usual bias, the Question Time Leaders Special was good, because it is probably be the only time in this election campaign when party leaders will take questions from a live audience.

For those who would like to read more about the programme as it happened, see the Daily Mail (here and here) as well as The Guardian.

When I was in the US recently, I met up with two former classmates of mine, both devout Catholics, who said that they ‘just loved’ BBC America and BBC World Service.  They were shocked when I said I hardly watched the Beeb anymore. 

Twenty years ago the BBC produced high-quality, objective programmes and news — the main reasons that I watched its channels.

Over the past decade, the Corporation has moved ever leftward in virtually all its programming.  I stopped watching BBC News regularly when I woke up one morning in 2004 to see a News 24 reporter, Barbara Plett, burst into tears on air announcing that Yassar Arafat had died.  Please — give me a break: the man started his career in terrorism with the PLO then legitimised himself as a politician

The following year, BBC News did a poor job in reporting on the 2005 London bombings, giving an excessive amount of coverage to apologists for the bombers.

Furthermore, BBC Breakfast has been onside with politically correct social engineering since the mid-1990s. 

And if you lodge a complaint with the Beeb and are fortunate enough to be given a soundbite on Raymond Snoddy’s (ex-Financial Times) brief show on Saturdays before 8 a.m., he always tells you, with the help of a BBC producer or head of department, why you are wrong.  As we all know, Auntie Beeb is always right.   

Within the past couple of years, however, the rest of their programming has taken a pro-Labour turn.  Even Have I Got News for You (HIGNIFY) isn’t as funny anymore.  Everyone on it snipes regularly at the Tories and now at their coalition partners, the LibDems.  Even Private Eye editor and satirist Ian Hislop has fallen prey to the predominant leftist memes.  It used to be comedian Paul Merton for the left and Hislop for the right as team captains, but now that they’re all firmly on the left, the show has lost its edge.

So, that leaves us in the mousehole watching only a couple of the cooking series — Masterchef (in all its guises) and Great British Menu.  I haven’t seen the former get politicised yet, although it’s probably only a matter of time.  However, the current series of Great British Menu seems to feature a stitch-up of an accomplished chef in favour of a more ordinary one in ingredients and style.  Recently, Jason Atherton gave Tristan Welch a right pasting in judging, throwing him out of the competition with unbelievably low scores.  Welch won last year for London and the South East for his outstanding pudding (that’s the traditional word for ‘dessert’, by the way).  This year’s was no exception, yet Atherton (whom I previously admired but have gone off totally now) let a chef with a mediocre recipe win.  It was pretty clear that Atherton and the other regions’ chefs, with the exception of Northern Ireland’s Richard Corrigan, judged their own threesome of hopefuls in the same way.  Why would one want sub-standard food at a banquet for the Prince of Wales, his consort the Duchess of Cornwall and the nation’s top real food producers?  ‘Banquet’ implies grandeur and elegance.  But, no, it seems that the BBC must change the way we think about banquets, too.

On to the BBC’s current affairs programmes by way of closing.  I’m heartened to read that I’m not the only one fed up with them.  Last week’s Question Time (shown on Thursdays after the 10 p.m. news) created a furore; Labourites spin doctor Alastair Campbell and ex-Mirror editor Piers Morgan were on the panel. Campbell and Morgan have never held elected office.  The BBC, it seems, wanted the new Coalition to send two Cabinet ministers to balance the panel.  The Coalition said no, although they did send along senior Tory MP John Redwood and former LibDem MP Susan Kramer.  That’s good enough.  

A number of people watching at home are disgruntled with the BBC’s tiresome proselytising for the left.  It is difficult for ordinary members of the public to obtain tickets to see the show, because the BBC reserves these for Labour sympathisers who have become increasingly assertive — aggressive, one might say — and noisy during the show.  Guido Fawkes’s readers have had enough (hope they don’t mind my borrowing a couple prescient comments):

Cleggometer: Time for this government to stop the Beeb from inviting sycophants of the last government from appearing on current affairs programmes. How can the national audience get a representative view of politics from inviting ex-spin doctors and ex-national rag editors? Good on the government not to send anyone …

revolting peasant: Would this be a good time to repeat my tale of a friend who was told her application for three tickets to the Woking edition of QT before the election had been successful. Only for the offer to be withdrawn by QT the following day because she was a floating voter and not a Labour supporter.
The same QT that is now self righteously claiming to be impartial

Even the BBC website received comments from disgruntled viewers:

jbatpersonal: The BBC are displaying their usual Labour party bias by inviting an unelected spin doctor TO SPEAK ON BEHALF OF THE LABOUR PARTY.
QT has got it utterly wrong. If they must have Campbell on the panel he should be there to speak as a commentator and NOT to represent the Labour party. He may well have controlled the Labour party but he has never been near any election himself. His twisted and vengeful actions have cost this country dearly. He has no authority to speak on behalf of Labour.
We used to enjoy watching QT but it is quite clear over recent months it has become increasingly biased and dysfunctional. Consequently we are switching off in protest. You won’t worry about the loss of two viewers, but we do ask the BBC to change the management and get back to discussing important political questions of the day with genuine representatives of political parties and independent commentators. Then you may get us to watch again

Many people living outside the UK are unaware that every television-owning household in the country has to pay for the BBC.  During the 1990s it emerged that poor single mothers were given prison sentences for non-payment of their annual TV licences.  Since then, these matters have been dealt with somewhat differently.  However, people who do not own televisions are hassled by TV Licensing, an outsourced body which bills and monitors these payments.  Charles Moore documents his own experiences and those of the public in his weekly Spectator column.

In a future post, I’ll feature the story of Lord Reith, a staunch Scottish Presbyterian who asked God for direction one Sunday at church in London.  He ended up founding the BBC, whose remit, as he put it, was to inform, educate and entertain.  I do wonder what he would make of it all now.  Not a single BBC channel on television or radio reflects a balanced, impartial perspective.  I’d love to be able to watch and listen to more of the Beeb, but for now, that’s a non-starter. 

That’s why, if you live overseas, I would advise you to exercise discernment when watching BBC News and documentaries.

For further reading:

Biased BBC

David Dimbleby’s blast at BBC communications: ‘Nobody knows what anybody else is doing’

Question Time row as No10 refuses to field Cabinet minister to face Alastair Campbell

Has the BBC’s Question Time Had Its Day?

No. 10 hits back at BBCQT. Re Ali C.

© Churchmouse and Churchmouse Campanologist, 2009-2020. Unauthorized use and/or duplication of this material without express and written permission from this blog’s author and/or owner is strictly prohibited. Excerpts and links may be used, provided that full and clear credit is given to Churchmouse and Churchmouse Campanologist with appropriate and specific direction to the original content.
WHAT DOES THIS MEAN? If you wish to borrow, 1) please use the link from the post, 2) give credit to Churchmouse and Churchmouse Campanologist, 3) copy only selected paragraphs from the post — not all of it.
PLAGIARISERS will be named and shamed.
First case: June 2-3, 2011 — resolved

Creative Commons License
Churchmouse Campanologist by Churchmouse is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 2.0 UK: England & Wales License.
Permissions beyond the scope of this license may be available at

Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Join 1,382 other followers


Calendar of posts

January 2020
« Dec    
262728293031 - The internets fastest growing blog directory
Powered by WebRing.
This site is a member of WebRing.
To browse visit Here.

Blog Stats

  • 1,556,892 hits