‘We do not have to destroy America with missiles; America will destroy itself from within.’ — Nikita Khruschev
Many young Protestant seminarians and pastors are taking an increasingly political position towards the Gospel. This is not without its dangers.
Churchmouse Campanologist has already explored Communist infiltration in the Catholic Church, now it looks at the history of the social Gospel in the United States.
Many clergymen promoting the social Gospel might be surprised to find out that it came about at the same time that Pope St Pius X declared Modernism –elevating man above God through communism and moral relativism — a heresy. Believe it or not, this was already over a century ago. Whilst I don’t expect Protestants to acknowledge what a Pope says, it would be useful for them to do so on this occasion.
How it started
Walter Rauschenbusch (1861 – 1918), Professor of Church History at Rochester Theological Seminary, is known as the ‘Father of the Social Gospel’. You might be interested to know that John D Rockefeller funded this seminary, along with many others in the United States.
Dr Rauschenbusch grew up in a German Lutheran family but became a Baptist pastor prior to his professorship. His status as a professor gave him the platform to become an influential theologian. He wrote two books, Christianising the Social Order and A Theology for the Social Gospel. He considered himself steeped in ‘higher criticism’ and well-versed in socialism. He proposed a more relevant and compassionate Gospel designed to change the emphasis and direction of American Protestantism. He also introduced the idea of an earthly Kingdom achieved through socialism. He posited that Jesus didn’t come to save sinners but had a ‘social passion’ for society. Does that sound familiar? It’s surprising what our forebears thought of such a long time ago, isn’t it?
In 1907, he met with the Fabians (socialists) in England. Remember, Margaret Sanger also met with Fabians and had one heck of a time. As with Mrs Sanger, the Fabians advised a gentle, peaceful, sensible approach to this transformation. Also, as with Mrs Sanger, they proposed propaganda and infiltration to achieve their goals. In Rauschenbusch’s case the targets were to be universities, seminaries and churches.
A year later John D Rockefeller helped Rauschenbusch and the Fabian Revd Harry Ward — remember this name — to fund the establishment of the Federal Council of Churches. This would eventually become the National Council of Churches. We now have the World Council of Churches, which is very much aligned with the United Nations and global agendas. Jesus Christ doesn’t get a look in.
Don’t forget that Rockefeller also helped fund eugenics departments, propaganda and communitarian programmes. Many people think Rockefeller was a conservative Baptist businessman, but he was the daddy of all ‘change agents’ — the original and best.
The social Gospel movement picked up steam for the next several decades. Nowadays, it would be difficult to find a university, seminary or church that didn’t propose some form of moral relativism and social justice programme.
Committee on Un-American Activities — 1953
In 1953 the Revd Harry Ward’s name popped up in the McCarthy hearings on Un-American Activities. Here is what the transcripts from July 1953 said (emphasis in the original).
Manning Johnson, a former senior member of the Communist Party, answered questions from Robert Kunzig, Chief Counsel for the committee. What follows is part of his testimony:
- ‘Dr Harry F Ward, for many years, has been the chief architect for Communist infiltration and subversion in the religious field.’
- Harry Ward taught ‘Christian Ethics’ at the Rockefeller-funded Union Theological Seminary, presided over the Federal Council of Churches, chaired the American Civil Liberties Union. He also worked with the YMCA, YWCA and the Interchurch World Movement.
- William Z Foster, General Secretary of the Communist Party USA, said, ‘Communists must ever be keen to cultivate the democratic spirit of mutual tolerance among the religious sects … A still greater lesson for us to learn, however, is how to work freely with religious strata for the accomplishment of democratic mass objectives… A very serious mistake of the American left wing during many years … has been its attempt arbitrarily to wave aside religious sentiments among the masses. Reactionary forces [mainly concerned Christians] have already known how to work take advantage of this shortsighted sectarian error … In recent years, however, the Communist Party, with its policy of ‘the outstretched hand’ has done much to overcome the harmful left-wing narrowness of former years and to develop a more healthy cooperation with the religious masses.’
- Deceit was a major policy of Communist propaganda and activity: ‘They made fine gestures and honeyed words to the church people which could be well likened unto the song of the fabled sea nymphs luring millions to moral decay, spiritual death and spiritual slavery.’
- The Revd Harry F Ward also headed the Methodist Federation for Social Service, or the Methodist Federation for Social Action. He ‘was invaluable to the Communist Party … because through it the Party was able to get contacts with thousands of ministers all over the country … Quite a few ministers, for example, participated in the united front known as the American League Against War and Fascism … In fact, they were so deeply involved through Harry F. Ward that they became the spokesmen — the advocates, the builders and the leaders of this most important Communist front that engaged in everything from simple assault on a government to espionage, sabotage and the overthrow of the Government.’
- Exhibit No. 21 presented to the committee was The Daily Worker of May 7, 1953, which reported on a dinner held in Dr Ward’s honour: ‘New World Review, a progressive monthly devoted to circulating the truth about the Socialist and People’s Democracies abroad … brough out several hundred friends and former students of Dr Ward, and some of those who knew him well like Corliss Lamont [the Communist son of Thomas Lamont, chairman of the J P Morgan banking conglomerate] … told the others of how Dr Ward’s teachings enriched them personally and how his tremendous work for brotherhood, peace and justice has influenced the nation.’
- The Communists infiltrated and poisoned the religious organisations of America wherever possible: ‘Once the tactic of infiltrating religious organisations was set by the Kremlin, the actual mechanics of implementing the ‘new line’ was a question of following … the church movement in Russia, where the Communists discovered that the destruction of religion could proceed much faster through infiltration of the church by Communist agents operating within the church itself … The infiltration tactic in this country would have to adapt itself to American conditions … In the earliest stages it was determined that with only small forces available it would be necessary to concentrate Communist agents in the seminaries and divinity schools. The practical conclusion drawn by the Red leaders was that these institutions would make it possible for a small Communist minority to influence the ideology of future clergymen … The idea was to divert the emphasis of clerical thinking from the spiritual to the material … Instead of emphasis toards the spiritual matters of the soul, the new and heavy emphasis was to deal with those matters which, in the main, led toward the Communist program of ‘immediate demands’ [or ‘felt needs’].
Admittedly, this is a disturbing account to read. As with the aforementioned Catholic story, some people think that traditionalists sit around dreaming up these accounts. But, you have to ask yourself — Protestant or Catholic — whether the church services you attend now are the same ones your grandparents attended. Are the sermons you hear about Biblical truths? Or are they feel-good talks and calls to work for social justice?
The eternal Truth as revealed in the Holy Bible does not change. It’s the same yesterday, today and always. It has nothing to do with making Jesus out to be a social justice warrior. It has to do with faith and grace and repentance.
Many mainstream Protestant denominations are ruined almost beyond repair. Be careful about what you take to heart and what you preach. All is not what it seems.
‘I am the way, the truth, and the life. No one comes to the Father except through me.’ (John 14:6)
You can find out more here.
For more articles on postmodernism, click here.
9 comments
August 12, 2009 at 9:14 am
Antonella Oliver
Dear Churchmouse
A very interestng and informative “blog”…..which I have to read a few times to digest all it says and take in.
Thank You.
LikeLike
August 12, 2009 at 9:20 am
churchmouse
Thanks so much for your comment, Antonella! It’s always great to hear from you! 🙂
If you like, you can focus on the parts highlighted in bold. In short, it’s all about the Communist Party being able to infiltrate US seminaries and churches and spreading pleasant-sounding propaganda. (My favourite phrase from the testimony was ‘honeyed words to the church people’).
And, all of this was (in some cases ‘is’) supported by big money, intentionally or otherwise. If you click on the Corliss Lamont link, you’ll find out how many donations he made to elite prep schools and universities! Scary! 😯
LikeLike
August 13, 2009 at 7:44 am
Antonella Oliver
Wow Churchmouse….you seem to do a lot of research ang get a lot of information…..that is great. May I ask a personal question….you need not answer if you dont want to….
Are you perhaps a Priest ? A Catholic Priest ? or just a person who is very interested in all the Church does etc ?
Many thanks for such thought provoking articles
LikeLike
August 13, 2009 at 7:52 am
Antonella Oliver
By the way I thought communism has collapsed and the Fall of the Berlin Wall, the Liberation of Eastern Europe, the rebirth of the Russian republics, the rise of democracy and the philosophy of human rights.
In decades to come historians will puzzle over the cataclysmic events of the 1980 and 90’s trying to figure out how it could have happened. And most will be unaware that it was the work of Mary the Mother of God who weeps for peace and gathers her faithful from every land and with the prayers of her children, what wonders she has achieved.
A new age of peace has dawned “not through presidents but through prayer”. All of us who pray and fast and sacrifice and live a good christian life and who believe and trust our Lady – we too have had a part in ushering in this new age.
What do you think ?
LikeLike
August 13, 2009 at 8:24 am
churchmouse
Hi, Antonella!
Many thanks for the compliment about being a priest! (Wow, what a beautiful thing to read!) My mother often called me ‘the theologian of the family’. (It was all thanks to her, really.) No, I’m not a priest, although I used to ‘play church’ a lot when I was little! 😉
I’m really interested in what’s happening to Christianity lately. Are we on the right track? What perils do we need to watch out for? Do we really know what other denominations believe? Why do we demonise them so at times?
It seems that most people have quite an individualised view of Christianity: how it affects them personally. That’s where it appears to stop for many. I just enjoy reading about Christianity and always wonder if we can expand our vision and work more closely together so that we don’t become weakened by moral relativism or indifferentism (acedia). Maybe most true Christians are doing it best by showing a good example to others at all times. Maybe that’s what it’s all about.
Yes, I think continued prayer can help effect change, although it may take time to see the results.
I am concerned about leftist influences on our churches. By and large, I see and hear fewer Scriptural references (my readers and Gabriella’s are exceptions, of course). I would like to see a return to Biblical truths and more traditional liturgies in our churches.
Communism never really died. It’s certainly less of an influence in Europe, but a lot of ex-KGB people still have a lot of power and, now, money. When one reads about oligarchs one generally finds a father or grandfather who was a member of the KGB.
There is quite a lot of militant leftism and progressivism in the US. Some of this is a holdover from the student radicalism of 1968, which has split the Democratic Party in two. The current administration is a definite departure from previous ones — much less centrist. It certainly appears to disregard American history and the Constitution.
Sorry for the lengthy response! Hope this helps answer some of your questions! 🙂
LikeLike
August 13, 2009 at 9:03 am
Antonella Oliver
Oh yes…it would be great to return to Biblial Truths and Traditional Liturgies and it would be great if Christians would be united…maybe one day but not in my lifetime !!!
Maybe Communism was not eradicated completely because of power and money……lets hope it will slowly die……..because its ideologies are intrinsically evil.
Ciao and have a good day
p.s. you certainly know your Theology….you are probably a priest at heart.
LikeLike
August 13, 2009 at 8:07 pm
churchmouse
Well, let’s pray and fast and hope, Antonella, that we’re eventually all united. One day, it will happen! If not for us, then a future generation! 🙂
I really hope Communism will self-destruct. It is so devious and so vile. We can continue to pray and fast for that, too!
I love your p.s. Thanks **so** much! You’ve made my month! 🙂
Have a good day tomorrow!
LikeLike
August 16, 2009 at 2:34 am
Formerly Ipswich
Would be interesting to read such a piece about the Marxist SJ’s roaming the world with red flags and Das Kapital under their arms. Communism took a deep interest in the Romanist church, something called Vatican II i believe…..
LikeLike
August 16, 2009 at 2:52 am
churchmouse
Hello! Thanks for your comment! See the Saul Alinsky post of August 13:
as a starter. Later next week, I shall be exploring the Catholic connection further, so be sure to visit again.
However — Marxism has permeated nearly all Christian denominations, with the possible exception of Calvinism (for now, anyway).
LikeLike